What is Wealth?
Wealth, Values, and Society Have Transformed
By Jim Harris
Wealth. Millennials have a far different view of it than their boomer parents.
While young adults generally do not have much accumulated wealth, millennials have about half of what their boomer parents did at this point in their lives. The median net worth of millennial households is $12,500, while boomers had $20,700 at the same age in 1983.
Young people are graduating from college and university with more debt than ever before. This is one of the key factors contributing to millennials’ lower net worth. Half of Canadian students graduate with an average of $28,000 in debt. According to the Ontario Student Assistance Program, it takes the average new graduate typically nine-and-a-half years to repay their loans. As a result, a staggering 51% of millennials hold a second job to make ends meet.
It takes millennials an average of 29 years to save enough to afford a home in Canada’s biggest cities. The Generation Squeeze Report calls the affordability gap between baby boomers and their children an “emergency.”
Rapid Rise of the Sharing Economy
Millennials have innovative approaches to lowering their cost of living and defining wealth. The most expensive asset that Canadian families own is their home, but millennials are living at home longer than ever before to save money. In Canada, 35% of millennials are living with their parents.
Canadians’ second largest asset is a car. When I was a teenager, having your own car made you the envy of all your friends. Today, many millennials don’t bother to get a driver’s license. They can use rideshare services. Not only is it cheaper than car ownership, it’s more convenient. You don’t have to put on winter tires, or make appointments for oil changes, or worry about finding parking spots—which can be difficult in big cities—or worry about getting parking tickets.
But the biggest expense of car ownership? It’s the value of our time spent driving. Here’s a staggering stat: the average North American wastes 273 minutes a week commuting (228 hours/year or 5.7 work weeks a year!). The average wage in Canada is $26.83 an hour. So the cost of spending time in traffic is about $6,104 per employee per year.
By taking rideshare services like Uber and Lyft, millennials are having that portion of their life returned to them. While being driven they can work on a laptop, talk to friends on the phone, or have conference calls for work. Uber and Lyft – and eventually autonomous vehicles – free up the most precious of all commodities: time.
Micro mobility (defined as shared bikes, e-bikes, and e-scooters) has the potential to further disrupt urban transpiration and deliver substantial benefits by lowering travel costs, reducing traffic congestion, and decreasing the need for parking.
By analyzing more than 50 million car trips, INRIX Research found that 48% of all car trips in the most congested North American cities are less than three miles long. If a fraction of these trips were replaced with scooter and bike trips, cities could reap significant benefits. Many millennials do not equate physical assets, like cars, with wealth. What is valued is being able to quickly get to where you want, and over short distances micro mobility services certainly are faster than cars.
Sharing Economy; The Experience Economy
I interviewed the CEO of a start up who was staying with his extended family in a luxury property on the coast of Florida for $500 a night. It had five bedrooms, was right on the beach, and was worth $3 million. He thought, “this is crazy! A $3 million asset that I get to use for $500 a night. I could never put my entire family up in a luxury hotel for this little. It would be three times more expensive. And we wouldn’t all be together as we are here.”
I stay in a lot of hotel rooms because of my work. And a hotel room is a hotel room is a hotel room – even if it’s the Four Seasons. The average hotel room in North America is 325 square feet.
Which would you rather stay in when you’re staying in Amsterdam: a 325 square foot hotel, or a $1 million houseboat tied up in a canal? Which are you more likely to talk about to your friends and family when you are back home?
The Seven Ds of Disruption
The music industry is a great example for exploring the seven Ds of disruptive innovation: Digitized, Deceptive, Disruptive, Dematerialized, Demonetized, Democratized and Deflationary.
When I grew up, I bought vinyl records to listen to music. And then eight tracks. Then cassettes. Then CDs. When I went through my age when you acquired music, you owned the physical media.
Today we stream music. And because of smartphones and bandwidth you can have all the music you want with you at all times.
Once music was digitized, it dematerialized, demonetized, and was democratized. And all of that has been hugely disruptive to the music industry.
The trend was initially deceptive. None of the major record labels were able to transform fast enough, leaving it to Apple, and later Spotify, to redefine the business model for music. While it’s true that some millennials are now collecting vinyl, which has seen a resurgence, for the majority of listeners it’s important to have access to all music whenever, wherever.
Up until the 1990s, you were forced you to buy an entire album to get just the one song that you wanted. Today you can buy a single song for 99 cents from iTunes, or listen to it as often as you want as part of your Spotify streaming service. The cost of music has dramatically decreased and demonetized. (I won’t speak to the impact on arts and artists – that’s for another column).
Because of demonetization, music or more affordable than ever before which means it’s been democratized—more people can afford it and you can listen to any music anywhere, any time. (And you don’t have to lug around 2,000 lbs of vinyl records).
But more importantly, music is deflationary. The percentage of my disposable income when I was growing that was spent on music was FAR larger for people at the same age today. While millennials have less disposable income, some important items are significantly less expensive on a relative basis because of disruptive innovation. For instance, with Skype and Zoom and Facetime, long distance calls are now inexpensive or free.
Wealth in The Era of Climate Crisis
We are living in a time of the greatest crisis humanity has ever faced. Scientist have repeatedly warned us that unless we dramatically change business as usual and radically decrease our carbon emissions, we will continue with irreversible climate change.
Millennials stand to inherit $68 trillion of wealth as their baby boomer parents pass away between now and 2030, according to Coldwell Banker. But the future value of that “wealth” will be irrelevant if planetary eco system are no longer sustainable.
Millennials have different sets of values. You can’t have financial wealth on a dead planet. The climate crisis is providing an opportunity to redefine what is important in life: Redefine wealth. Redefine success. Here’s a story to drive home the point. Do we live to work? Or do we work to live?
The Mexican Fisherman
There’s a powerful story about a burned-out Wall Street trader, who decided to take some holidays. He traveled to Mexico and was staying at a five star resort right on the beach.
As was his pattern, every morning he would get up at 4 am, even though he was on holiday, and walk on the beach. Every morning as the sun was rising he saw a Mexican come to the beach and begin fishing.
After a few days the Wall Street broker went up to the Mexican and asked him, “What are you doing?”
The Mexican replied, “I come here to fish, to catch a fish and feed my family.”
“What is your life like?” Asked the broker.
“Well, I catch a fish and go home. We have the fish for lunch. Then in the afternoon I play with the children. We have dinner. We put the kids to bed. I make love to my wife and we go to sleep. Then the next morning I get up early and come and fish. “
“Ah,” said the broker, “I can help you.:
“How is that?” asked the Mexican.
“Well, you should get another fishing rod and catch two fish every day.”
“So that you can sell one fish in the market.”
“And why is that?”
“So that you can save your money and eventually buy a boat.”
“And what do I need a boat for?”
“So that you can fish initially with fishing lines, but eventually with nets.”
“And why is that?”
“So that you can buy more boats and hire people to do the fishing for you.”
“Well this is where it gets interesting. So that you can build a canning plant right here on the island and become a vertically integrated international fish canning company.”
“And why would I want to spend all the time away from my family to do that?”
“Well, this is where I can help you. We do an IPO and you become filthy rich, which allows you to retire and fish on the beach every day . . . “
What is REAL Wealth?
There is a saying: “When the last tree has been cut down, the last fish caught, the last river poisoned, only then will we realize that one cannot eat money.”
Many millennials are re-defining wealth as wealth of experience. Living a life of rich experience. A life of joy. Of love.
Whether this shift is because of the financial restrictions that have been imposed on them as a generation, or because they have actively chosen it, many millennials are choosing to redefine wealth as experience, rather than material possessions.
Jim Harris is the author of the Blindsided which focuses on disruptive innovation. It is published in 80 countries worldwide and is a #1 international bestseller. You can follow him on Twitter @JimHarris or email him at email@example.com
What is Wealth
What is Wealth
Top Tech Trends in Canada for 2020 A new decade begins with exciting new opportunities for making your business tech-savvyBy Cara Bedford In the best-selling 1997 book The Innovator’s Dilemma, Clayton M. Christensen, a Harvard Business School professor, introduced the term disruptive technology. The disruptive technologies of the past decades included the telephone, the television,
Your Digital Undertaker Who Will Get your Twitter Followers When You Die, and Other Things You Never Considered By Lisa Sadach We all know technology changes the way we live, but how does it change the way we die? In 2017, Sharon Hartung, author of Your Digital Undertaker, faced a difficult and, unfortunately, common situation.
The Last Word: AI in 2020 By Adam Allouba, Partner, Dentons Every new technology brings new risks and opportunities, and artificial intelligence is no exception. AI forces us to consider both optimistic and pessimistic scenarios, previously reserved for science fiction. While it will take an army of thinkers to unravel the cultural, sociological, economic and
Thriving During Times of Transformation Why Risk Could Be Your Company’s Safest Option By Lisa Sadach Is there someone who thinks they can do your job better? Are you making sure you are proving them wrong? Dr. Marvin Washington, an independent consultant and a professor at the University of Alberta’s Alberta School of Business, has made
The Future of Insurance Disrupting a Traditional IndustryBy Lisa Sadach How can an industry that creates a mandatory product be disrupted? This is a question that has plagued Canadian auto insurance providers for more than a decade. Auto insurance is a legally required product across Canada that is heavily regulated and extremely slow to change.
When Walmart Met Blockchain How a multinational business was able to become even more productive.By Stephan Boissonneault When Louden Owen, CEO of DLT Labs in Toronto, was in a bar in Germany, the bartender asked him what he did for work. “I’m in something called blockchain,” Owen replied casually, but the bartender responded and “Oh,
We are the Outsiders…with a fresh perspective If you were to ask me who is the wealthiest person I know, I would say my dad. Second would be my five-year-old son. These are the happiest people I know, and for that reason I believe they are the wealthiest. When I think of wealth, my first
Why a More People-Centered Approach to Data Science Can Help Societies Thrive By David Bray “It was the best of times, it was the worst of times…” So begins Charles Dickens’ A Tale of Two Cites— with the narrator later noting that this characterization of contrasting superlatives represents a common thread throughout history. Nowadays, the same
The Wealthy Blogger Bridget Casey is helping a new generation with their finances By Breanna Mroczek In 1989 the book The Wealthy Barber: The Common Sense Guide to Successful Financial Planning, penned by then-27-year-old David Chilton, was published. It consisted of a series of fables about twenty-something-year-old adults to relay financial advice. It sold more